Our funds can get stuck when:

Position and current exit evidence

Withdrawal pin: Ethereum block 25,990,633, 16 September 2026, 14:27:59 UTC. Targeted withdrawal sequences were added September 17 at that same archived state. NOCA is the largest shareholder with 42.08% of the vault and a 2,213.52 WETH gross claim. Only 262.98 WETH is idle across the vault. With the operator processing our request first, we received 2,208.68 WETH and cleared our shares. After all other holders were paid first, the operator’s remaining unwind paid us 2,200.21 WETH, leaving 3.97 WETH unpaid.

A combined run was more restrictive: after all 125 other holder requests were paid and outside Curve LPs exited, the remaining LP quoted only 32,040 BOLD against 2.836m BOLD debt. The BOLD route failed. An existing USDC exit route and collateral withdrawal raised our recovery from 101.00 to 1,988.75 WETH, leaving a 250.83 WETH claim behind an open loan at 121% collateralization. That fallback is a conditional test, not a recommended operating level or a maximum recovery bound.

Funding: Spark since 23 October 2026 (block 26,256,381, 16:00:11 UTC). The same treasury Safe borrows 2,171.03 WETH on Spark. On 23 October it took that loan to repay its Morpho wstETH/WETH loan in full and withdrew the Morpho collateral; the 1,900 wstETH now sits idle in the Safe. The Spark loan shares one account with the Compound strategy’s 9.04m USDS debt, against 8,680.17 wstETH of shared collateral, at health factor 1.532. An ETH price fall of 45.6%, to about $1,306, makes the account liquidatable. In a fork at $1,300, a liquidator repaid half the USDS debt and seized 2,964.60 wstETH of the shared collateral, leaving the WETH debt in place. The loan is still not solely a Liquity funding loan: the Morpho borrowing it replaced funded a 1,000 WETH vault deposit and a 1,166 WETH purchase of liquid wstETH.

At the September pin, without an unwind, we recovered 262.57 WETH if first and zero after another holder consumed the available cash. The original full-vault-unwind benchmark also repaid the then Morpho loan and recovered all collateral. Those financing tests, including the 30-day Morpho lender-run simulation, describe the closed Morpho loan and are superseded. The detailed withdrawal investigation covers ordering, requests, underlying Curve liquidity, controls, liquidation, branch shutdown and repayment from separate treasury assets.

Current carry at the October 23 pin: the vault’s share price grew at 4.45% APY over 30 days and 4.35% over 14 days; share-price growth is what holders earn before the request fee. On NOCA’s 2,223.17 WETH claim, 37.05% of the vault, that is about 99.0 WETH a year against 40.8 WETH a year of Spark interest at 1.86% APR, a carry of about +58 WETH a year when the whole loan is charged to the vault. The 30-day yield is below the communicated 6% floor, and the vault’s 6,000.31 WETH NAV exceeds the 5,000 ETH that floor covers.

Historical economics below: 19 August 2026 inputs, not a current yield quote. Subsidy funding and the yield decomposition have not been refreshed.

The provisional annualized net-yield estimate is 6.51% after management and performance fees but before the 0.40% entry/exit spread and unwind costs. A discretionary weekly WETH transfer contributes 5.89 points, with 1.593 WETH left in the payer wallet against a 1.74 WETH four-week average payment. Without it, the estimate falls to 1.21% versus 2.185% for holding wstETH. Depositor funds are controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe of bare EOAs with no timelock, and no incorporated operator or named principals were verified from the materials reviewed.

Liquity’s team separately communicated to NOCA that it will maintain 6% net APY after fees for total vault NAV up to 5,000 ETH through Q1 2027 and cover NOCA’s 20bp entry fee. That commitment is not encoded in the vault or visibly escrowed. The 20bp exit fee and unwind costs remain.

Mechanism and true exposure

WETH enters an ERC-4626 vault, is converted to wstETH and posted to a Liquity V2 trove. The trove mints BOLD, which is deployed in a Curve BOLD/USDC LP and staked in its gauge, with a small Uniswap V4 position also present. At the September 16 pin, the vault held 4,013.90 wstETH collateral, owed 6.740m BOLD at 0.75% annual interest, held 57.05% of Curve pool LP supply, and kept 5.00% of its NAV idle. The name still does not describe the actual collateral: this trove holds wstETH. The treasury’s Spark borrowing adds a financing layer outside the vault; vault shares and Spark debt cannot be cancelled internally. Exiting requires actual WETH to reach Spark, and withdrawing collateral must leave the account healthy against the Compound strategy’s remaining USDS debt.

The August oracle review identified two vault oracle paths. IPOR NAV uses Chainlink-based WETH/wstETH inputs and a Pyth BOLD adapter; the adapter calls getPriceUnsafe, and the deployed manager does not enforce its returned publish time. Liquity liquidation separately uses Chainlink STETH/USD multiplied by the wstETH/STETH exchange rate, with a one-hour heartbeat, 24-hour staleness threshold and ETH/USD/exchange-rate fallback (Liquity source, accessed 20 Aug 2026).

Capital, return, control and exit paths

Solid petrol lines are assets or exits; dashed petrol is debt; teal is return; coral is the vault-specific subsidy. Dotted lines are fees, control or dependencies.

Operator subsidy1 week funded2-of-3 Safeno timelockIPOR NAV feedsChainlink ETH + Pyth BOLDLiquity wstETH oracleChainlink stETH/USDDepositorWETHIPOR Fusion vault15% idle WETHLiquity trovewstETH collateralBOLD debtInstant WETH exitup to idle bufferOperator unwindunstake, repay, releaseCurve BOLD/USDC LPstaked in gaugeIPOR + Sentinel fees0.50% mgmt + 10% perf. depositpost wstETH mintpair + stake fees + CRV + BOLD weekly WETH control share NAVliquidationidle WETHmanualWETH

Historical vault-only diagram: block 25,789,465, 19 August. Its 15% buffer and subsidy funding are historical; current idle cash is 5%. The external financing leg, now on Spark, is described above.

Net economics, benchmark and capacity

At the historical August 19 rates, staking yield minus BOLD interest plus Curve trading fees is −0.14% of NAV; CRV and gauge-wide BOLD incentives raise the pre-subsidy return to 1.84%. The 5.89-point WETH subsidy and 0.50% management plus 10% performance fees produce the provisional 6.51% estimate. IPOR Labs receives 0.30% management and 2% performance; Sentinel receives 0.20% and 8%. The estimate annualizes point-in-time staking, borrowing and reward inputs; it excludes the 0.40% entry/exit spread and unwind costs. The operator app showed 6.03%, and the difference remains unreconciled. A fixed 90.4 WETH annual subsidy dilutes as NAV grows; the supporting table shows that sensitivity. The Liquity-team commitment changes the commercial return floor through Q1 2027, but it does not explain the funding mechanism or make the observed weekly subsidy durable on-chain.

5.9 of the 6.5 yield points are a discretionary subsidy

−1.0−0.50.00.51.01.52.02.53.03.54.04.55.05.56.06.57.07.58.0annual return contribution, percentage pointswstETH stakingBOLD interestCurve swap feesCRV emissionsBOLD PILWETH subsidymanagement feeperformance feeNet yield+1.86-2.39+0.39+0.14+1.84+5.89-0.50-0.726.51

Source: Ethereum block 25,789,465, 19 Aug 2026. Lido staking rate from its live API on the same date; CRV emissions use the verified 1.0× rate. The operator app showed 6.03%; the 0.48-point difference remains unreconciled.

Exit, cost and latency

The operator must obtain BOLD, repay Liquity, release collateral and sell it for WETH. There is no verified service-time guarantee.

The combined shareholder/Curve run blocked the remaining BOLD exit even with a cooperative operator. Using the existing Curve exit fuse to receive 2.957m USDC, then selling it and 534.54 wstETH of permitted collateral, paid 1,988.75 WETH in total. 250.83 WETH remained. The loan still owed 2.836m BOLD; collateral withdrawals were constrained by its minimum ratio. Other BOLD sources and the final payout remain unverified. The same outside-Curve shock without prior shareholder exits allowed our smaller exit to complete, so sequencing changes the result.

Requests charge 0.20% in shares and expire 24 hours after creation. A delayed operator had 2,358.75 WETH ready, but the expired request and a direct redemption both failed while cash was reserved. Renewing the request and release paid 2,204.40 WETH, including a second request fee. Separately, a USDC freeze of the Curve pool blocked the top-up route, but buying BOLD through extra LP redemption allowed our full request to be paid. A failed route does not establish that every route fails.

With no Curve shock, processing all other requests before ours paid us 2,200.21 WETH, leaving a 3.97 WETH claim. Full-share redemption requires a 2% liquidity allowance plus reservations; small assets and reserved cash can prevent the last shares exiting.

At the September pin, Liquity ICR was 1.7701, giving 32.21% price headroom to the 120% liquidation threshold at fixed debt/collateral. This is distinct from the Spark account’s 1.532 health factor on October 23: Spark values wstETH at Lido’s exchange rate times ETH/USD, so the account is liquidated by an ETH price fall of about 45.6%, driven by its USDS debt, while the WETH debt grows with interest whenever the vault is illiquid. The full-collateral stETH sale quoted 0.0546% below input at the pin; 0.1638% is the mechanical three-times-slippage floor. Comparable historical stressed slippage and guaranteed 1/7/30-day exit capacity remain UNVERIFIED. Exact quantities, assumptions and fork receipts are in the withdrawal investigation.

Risks

IDRiskMechanism and current evidence
R1Privileged controlThe current 2-of-3 administrator Safe registered and executed a malicious fuse that drained 262.98 idle WETH on the fork; its Guardian function blocked withdrawals without a timelock. A former Alpha still holds the request-fee role and successfully set a 10% fee in a separate test. See the September 16 withdrawal investigation.
R2Strategy driftThe Alpha can materially change the position within the approved fuse set. A snapshot can become stale without a vault NAV movement; any material allocation or fuse change requires re-underwriting.
R3Liquidation and oracle divergenceCurrent ICR is 1.7701: a 32.21% oracle-price decline reaches the 120% minimum. At a mocked 35% decline, liquidation cleared BOLD debt and left 325.02 wstETH surplus. Funded closure failed at a mocked 50% branch price decline; closure after shutdown succeeded in a separate 60% case. IPOR NAV and Liquity use different prices. The August BOLD publish-time finding remains a separately unresolved oracle-control gap.
R4Subsidy and basisIn the historical August model, removing the vault-specific WETH transfer reduced measured net yield from 6.51% to 1.21%. Liquity communicated a 6% net floor up to 5,000 ETH through Q1 2027, but no on-chain escrow or funding schedule was verified. wstETH, BOLD or USDC divergence reaches NAV through the trove or LP.
R5Code and key recourseA privileged key used on another Sentinel vault acquired an unexplained EIP-7702 delegation. IPOR attributes its January 2026 legacy-vault drain to missing fuse validation plus a compromised delegation (post-mortem, accessed 20 Aug 2026). No incorporated operator or signed curator agreement was verified.
R6Withdrawal processing and liquidityEligible requests share release capacity; another requester left 711.35 WETH of our claim waiting for further operator action. After other holders and outside Curve LPs exited, a fallback paid 1,988.75 WETH and left 250.83 WETH behind an open loan at 121% collateralization. Expired requests and reserved cash blocked payment even after an unwind. Other BOLD sources, final recovery and operator timing remain unverified.
R7Liquity redemptionOther troves with lower quoted rates carry 12.349m BOLD debt at the new pin; eligibility and branch routing make this a conditional cushion. Redemptions can change the collateral/debt mix while LP exposure persists. Collecting liquidation surplus through the configured vault fuses remains unverified.
R8Spark funding, shared account and attributionSince 23 October the wallet owes 2,171.03 WETH on Spark, in one account with the Compound strategy’s 9.04m USDS debt, against 8,680.17 wstETH of shared collateral; health factor 1.532. An ETH fall of 45.6%, to about $1,306, makes the account liquidatable; in a fork, a USDS liquidation at $1,300 seized 2,964.60 wstETH of the shared collateral. Spark prices wstETH at Lido’s exchange rate, so a stETH market discount does not reach it. Spark’s WETH rate is 1.86% APR at 78.1% utilization; above its 90% kink it rises toward 77%. Spark governance can change parameters after a 48-hour delay, and a 3-of-5 Safe can pause the market at once, which blocks repayment, collateral withdrawal and liquidation. The Morpho borrowing this loan replaced funded a 1,000 WETH vault deposit and 1,166 WETH of liquid wstETH, so the debt is not solely Liquity funding. Vault shares cannot repay it.

Research gaps: R1/R2: Safe proposals do not capture every Alpha action, current pause, fuse change or retained request-fee key. Allocation and fuse-use drift require fresh strategy evidence; no low-noise threshold was agreed. R4: weekly performance reporting and a 14-day yield window answer different questions.

R6/R7: the September 16–17 forks verified competing eligible requests consuming shared release capacity, expiry after cash is ready, BOLD-route failure after combined shareholder and Curve exits, and partial fallback recovery with an open loan. Request coverage, competing releases, route capacity, issuer freezes and operator timing are not established by price and ICR observations. The 121% fallback collateral ratio is a simulation assumption. Final non-WETH residual exits and claimability of Liquity liquidation surplus still need mechanism-specific discovery and execution review; a zero or closed trove does not establish recovery of those claims.

R8: the Spark WETH rate against the vault’s yield, Spark pauses and freezes, and attribution of the shared account to this strategy remain gaps. The prior review recorded shared-account health-factor reference levels of 2 and 1.5, set for the USDS loan alone; the latter is about a 3.3% ETH fall from the pin.

IPOR later announced a separate OpenCover wrapper; this memo evaluates the uncovered base vault (IPOR announcement, accessed 20 Aug 2026).

Unresolved conditions

Trust and control

The current administrator Safe has three bare EOA owners and a two-signature threshold. Two keys sufficed for the tested custody drain and pause. One Alpha key can act within the configured fuses and determine unwind/release timing; one stale fee key can alter request economics. This is not a proof that trading permissions cannot cause loss with fewer than two keys. The IPOR DAO Safe is 4-of-6; both treasury Safes are 3-of-6 with the same EOA owners. The observed module lists were empty. All four nonce-filtered Safe queues returned zero pending transactions when checked in this session.

The funding loan now depends on Spark’s controls. Parameter, oracle and rate-model changes come from Sky governance through its pause proxy, after a 48-hour delay. Spark’s Freezer Mom can freeze or pause one or all markets at once; a 3-of-5 Safe whose five owners are wallets without contract code, Sky’s elected governance contract and Spark’s governance proxy can each call it. A pause blocks repayment, collateral withdrawal and liquidation. Anyone can trigger Spark’s kill switch when stETH/ETH falls to 0.95 or one of five other monitored feeds falls below its threshold; it disables new borrowing on every market but leaves repayment open. Three of that Safe’s five keys can therefore block repaying the funding loan and releasing its collateral.

Evidence boundary

The September 16 withdrawal investigation supersedes the older exit amounts and adds current ownership, financing, controls and local transaction execution. It preserves its pin, source hashes, eight original withdrawal tests and thirteen protocol stress scenarios. The September 17 targeted-exit evidence adds two staged withdrawal sequences and one smaller-exit Curve stress at the same pin. Six operator-processing sequences additionally test competing releases, late completion, a combined withdrawal run with fallback recovery and its no-shock control, and a USDC freeze. The October 23 funding evidence, at block 26,256,381, refreshes the funding leg and the vault’s realised yield: the five Safe transactions of the move, the Spark account, rate model, oracle and controls, the vault claim and share-price history, and a fork liquidation of the shared account on Anvil 1.7.1. Subsidy durability, historical stressed slippage and operator response commitments are not refreshed. A vault share balance alone cannot establish repayment of the Spark loan; direct-exit, control and funding-attribution gaps remain as described above.

The following paragraph describes the historical August economics evidence only.

Vault balances, roles, signer composition, delegation state, Liquity positions, redemption order and reward transfers were measured at Ethereum block 25,789,465; subsidy transfers cover mid-May through that block. The annualized yield is a point-in-time model, not a realized holding-period return. The Lido rate and public operator, IPOR and coverage statements are external inputs dated and linked above. The 6% net-return and entry-fee terms are a Liquity-team communication to NOCA, not an on-chain obligation. The deployed-code audit delta, BOLD freshness control, fee crystallization, operator-rate reconciliation, delegation purpose, legal recourse, forward subsidy funding and stressed exit remain unresolved. The D2, Vega-Lite and Great Tables sources beside this memo reproduce the exhibits.

Supporting evidence

Subsidy durability

The payer delivered 14.167 WETH from mid-May through the pinned block. The most recent seven weekly payments totalled 10.53 WETH; the latest four averaged 1.74 WETH. The payer wallet held 1.593 WETH. Over nine funded weeks, 51.5% of the depositor subsidy came from Liquity incentives and 48.5% from Sentinel cash.

Weekly WETH payments exceed the funded balance

28 Jun5 Jul12 Jul19 Jul26 Jul2 Aug9 Aug16 Aug0.00.51.01.52.0WETH paid per week1.221.201.151.601.581.562.21funded runway 1.593 WETH — one average week4-week average 1.74

Source: Ethereum block 25,789,465, 19 Aug 2026. Payer: Sentinel’s Atomist Safe and a contract it controls.

Capacity if the subsidy budget stays fixed

The operator stated that it intends to hold net yield near 6%, which would require increasing the WETH budget as the vault grows. The table isolates the observable floor case: 90.4 WETH per year spread across a larger NAV, net of the 0.40% round-trip spread. It holds CRV and gauge-wide BOLD rewards, borrow rates, market impact and the 15% idle policy constant, so it measures subsidy dilution, not executable strategy capacity.

Net APY and annual excess over wstETH if the 90.4 WETH subsidy stays fixed
Deposit NAV Share Subsidy APY Net APY Excess WETH/yr
Current vault 1,535 — 5.89% 6.51% —
+250 WETH 1,785 14% 5.07% 5.77% 7.9
+500 WETH 2,035 25% 4.44% 5.21% 13.0
+1,000 WETH 2,535 39% 3.57% 4.42% 18.1
+2,000 WETH 3,535 57% 2.56% 3.51% 18.2
+3,000 WETH 4,535 66% 1.99% 3.00% 12.1

Source: Ethereum block 25,789,465, 19 Aug 2026. Incentive held fixed at 90.4 WETH per year.